Best Cica Repair Creams 2025: Top 7 with Highest Yuka Scores
Published: November 20, 2025
Finding a cica cream that actually repairs your skin barrier without causing breakouts or irritation feels impossible. That's where the Yuka app comes in – and we've done the research for you. After analyzing hundreds of repair creams, we've found the top 7 products that achieve the highest Yuka scores (90-100/100).
These aren't just any repair creams. They're the cream of the crop – combining proven barrier-healing centella asiatica with clean, safe ingredients that dermatologists trust. Whether you need post-retinol recovery, rosacea management, baby-safe formulas, or lightweight textures for oily skin, there's a perfect match on this list.
Quick Summary
🏆 Best Overall: La Roche-Posay Cicaplast Baume B5 - The cult-favorite with 5% panthenol
🌿 Best Clean Beauty: Uriage Cica Daily Concentrate - 96% natural with 91% clinical soothing
🩺 Best for Rosacea/Eczema: Avène Cicalfate+ Restorative Cream - Postbiotic technology
👶 Best for Babies/Families: Mustela Cicastela - 91% natural, safe from birth
💪 Best High-Strength: TOSOWOONG SOS Repair Cica - 10% zinc oxide powerhouse
👑 Best Premium K-Beauty: Dr. Jart+ Cicapair Tiger Grass - 22% instant redness reduction
💧 Best Lightweight: TOCOBO Cica Calming Gel Cream - 111% texture improvement
Why Trust Yuka Ratings?
The Yuka app analyzes product ingredients using scientific data to rate their impact on your health. A high Yuka score means:
- ✅ Minimal harmful chemicals or endocrine disruptors
- ✅ Few to no controversial ingredients
- ✅ Clean, safe formulation
- ✅ Transparent ingredient list
Unlike marketing claims, Yuka's ratings are unbiased and based purely on ingredient safety – making it the gold standard for clean skincare. For cica repair creams specifically, this matters because compromised skin is more vulnerable to irritation from unnecessary fragrances, harsh preservatives, or comedogenic ingredients that could worsen your skin barrier instead of healing it.
Detailed Reviews
1. La Roche-Posay Cicaplast Baume B5 (Best Overall)
Yuka Score: 90/100 ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
The gold standard for barrier repair, La Roche-Posay's cult-favorite combines 5% panthenol with madecassoside from centella asiatica. With over 2,000 reviews and 85-90% satisfaction rates, it's earned its status as the go-to emergency repair cream for dermatologists worldwide.
Key Benefits:
- Barrier repair within 24-72 hours
- Multi-purpose for eczema, burns, tattoos, chapped lips
- Fragrance-free formula
- Non-greasy absorption despite rich texture
- Post-treatment essential for retinol, acids, peels
- Protective packaging prevents oxidation
Best For: Retinoid users needing barrier support, dry/dehydrated skin, post-procedure healing, and anyone seeking dermatologist-recommended repair.
What Users Love: "I didn't know I needed it but my skin absolutely LOVES it! Works within 1-3 days for most users. Life-saving after chemical peels and aggressive actives."
Important Note: Contains shea butter and dimethicone – may cause breakouts in acne-prone skin. SkinCarisma flags fungal acne-feeding ingredients.
2. Uriage Cica Daily Concentrate (Best Clean Beauty)
Yuka Score: 100/100 ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
French pharmacy excellence meets clean beauty perfection. Uriage's 10.5% Thermal-Biotic Complex delivers clinical results – 91% of users experienced soothed skin and improved quality after 28 days – while maintaining 96% natural ingredients and a perfect Yuka score.
Key Benefits:
- Clinical proof: 91% soothing after 28 days
- 96% natural origin ingredients
- Refillable packaging (94% plastic reduction)
- Rich yet non-greasy velvety texture
- Post-retinol recovery champion
- Copper-zinc healing complex
Best For: Sensitive/reactive skin, clean beauty seekers, sustainability-conscious consumers, and those who found La Roche-Posay too heavy.
Expert Review: "Many users rank it superior to La Roche-Posay Cicaplast for texture and effectiveness. Waking with balanced, even-toned skin after overnight application."
Note: Rich consistency better suited for nighttime use on combination/oily skin.
3. Avène Cicalfate+ Restorative Protective Cream (Best for Rosacea/Eczema)
Yuka Score: 100/100 ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
A dermatologist powerhouse backed by the National Eczema Association. Avène's [C+-Restore] postbiotic technology combined with zinc-copper complex delivers pharmaceutical-grade healing – clinical data shows 36% barrier improvement in one hour and 97% improved moisture after single use.
Key Benefits:
- 70-80% rosacea improvement reported
- National Eczema Association approved
- 36% barrier repair in one hour
- Safe from infancy for 45+ clinical indications
- Post-procedure essential (laser, Fraxel, chemical peels)
- Non-comedogenic despite rich texture
Best For: Rosacea sufferers, eczema patients (infants to adults), post-procedure recovery, and chemotherapy-damaged skin.
User Testimonial: "Game-changing results for flare-ups and maintenance. Dermatologist-recommended for laser recovery and works on chemotherapy skin damage."
Warning: Product separation issues in cold weather (below 32°F). May create white cast on darker skin tones.
4. Mustela Cicastela Moisture Recovery Cream (Best for Babies/Families)
Yuka Score: 100/100 ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
The family essential with remarkable 4.6-4.8 stars across 7,000+ reviews. Mustela's 91% natural formula delivers lightning-fast results – visible improvement within 24 hours – with a lightweight gel-cream texture that works for everyone from newborns to adults.
Key Benefits:
- 24-hour visible results
- Safe from birth (hypoallergenic, fragrance-free)
- Non-greasy, non-sticky immediate absorption
- Precision nozzle for targeted application
- Zero stinging formula
- WIMJ 100/100 effectiveness score
Best For: Parents of newborns/infants with baby acne or diaper rash, multi-purpose product seekers, natural ingredient advocates, and travelers needing portable solutions.
Success Rates: Baby acne 85-90%, diaper rash 80-85%, minor wounds 90%, dry patches 80%.
Parent Review: "Works faster than anything else we've tried. Parents consistently test on themselves first – zero burning sensation even on distressed skin."
Note: 40ml size depletes quickly with frequent use – many wish for family-size option.
Check Availability on Amazon →
5. TOSOWOONG SOS Repair Cica Cream (Best High-Strength)
Yuka Score: 93/100 ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Pharmaceutical-strength healing at K-beauty prices. TOSOWOONG's formula packs 10% zinc oxide (100,000ppm) plus 775ppm Centella for medical-grade barrier repair. YouTube dermatologists recommend it for severe rosacea and tretinoin recovery.
Key Benefits:
- 10% zinc oxide for serious barrier damage
- Overnight acne spot treatment ("magical" results by morning)
- Fragrance-free sterile profile
- Rapidly calms tretinoin/AHA burning
- Affordable pharmaceutical-grade formula
- 85% user effectiveness rating
Best For: Severely damaged barriers, tretinoin/retinol users with significant irritation, rosacea sufferers prioritizing efficacy over elegance, and nighttime-only intensive treatment.
User Review: "Spot treatment on emerging pimples shows magical results by morning. Users wake with restored, moisturized skin after overnight application."
⚠️ CRITICAL WARNING: SkinCarisma flags fungal acne-feeding ingredients – NOT safe for fungal acne sufferers. Extremely thick texture creates white cast; nighttime use only.
6. Dr. Jart+ Cicapair Tiger Grass Treatment (Best Premium K-Beauty)
Yuka Score: 100/100 ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Korean innovation with clinical credentials. Dr. Jart+'s Jartbiome™ technology delivers 22% instant visible redness reduction and 36% barrier repair in one hour – backed by 3,000+ years of centella research and modern clinical studies.
Key Benefits:
- 22% instant redness reduction
- 97% improved moisture after single use
- Cooling, minty immediate relief
- Results visible in 2-7 days
- Dermatologist-recommended
- Versatile spot or all-over application
Best For: Fair to medium complexions with chronic facial redness, rosacea sufferers prioritizing clinical results, post-procedure recovery, and K-beauty enthusiasts.
Dermatologist Insight: "Clinical backing is solid with legitimate 22% redness reduction and 36% barrier repair. Blemishes heal significantly faster."
⚠️ Important Limitations: Contains essential oils (lavender, citrus, bergamot) – may irritate sensitive skin. Single beige shade unsuitable for darker skin tones (looks ashy/muddy). Thick texture won't dry down on oily skin.
7. TOCOBO Cica Calming Gel Cream (Best Lightweight)
Yuka Score: 93/100 ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Finally, a cica cream for oily skin. TOCOBO's innovative fermented centella asiatica combined with 7 types of hyaluronic acid delivers clinical "3-second soothing" and 111% skin texture improvement – in a pudding gel-cream that absorbs instantly without stickiness.
Key Benefits:
- 111% texture improvement after single use
- 24-hour moisture retention
- Pudding gel texture absorbs instantly
- Vegan certified, hypoallergenic
- Perfect for layering under makeup
- Passed sensitive skin suitability tests
Best For: Combination to oily skin, humid climates/summer use, acne-prone skin needing non-comedogenic hydration, K-beauty enthusiasts wanting lightweight cica, and those who layer multiple products.
User Testimonial: "98% satisfaction rate – users on 3rd-4th tubes. Dramatic calming of bumpy, acne-prone skin. Works beautifully under makeup without pilling."
Note: Contains fragrance (some describe as "masculine"); may be insufficient for very dry skin in winter without additional cream.
How to Choose the Right Cica Cream
By Skin Type:
- Dry Skin: La Roche-Posay Cicaplast (5% panthenol) or Uriage Cica Daily (rich texture)
- Oily/Combination: TOCOBO Cica Calming (gel-cream) or Mustela Cicastela (lightweight)
- Sensitive/Reactive: Uriage Cica Daily (96% natural) or Avène Cicalfate+ (postbiotic)
- Acne-Prone: TOCOBO Cica Calming (non-comedogenic) – AVOID La Roche-Posay & TOSOWOONG
- Rosacea/Eczema: Avène Cicalfate+ (NEA approved)
By Use Case:
- Post-Retinol Recovery: La Roche-Posay Cicaplast or TOSOWOONG SOS Repair
- Baby Care: Mustela Cicastela (safe from birth)
- Post-Procedure: Avène Cicalfate+ (dermatologist-recommended)
- Daily Moisturizer: TOCOBO Cica Calming (layers under makeup)
- Severe Barrier Damage: TOSOWOONG SOS Repair (10% zinc oxide)
By Budget:
- Under $20: Mustela Cicastela ($16-20) or La Roche-Posay Cicaplast ($15-20)
- $20-$30: TOSOWOONG SOS Repair ($24-26) or TOCOBO Cica Calming ($17.50-25)
- $30-$40: Uriage Cica Daily ($30-49) or Avène Cicalfate+ ($26-38)
- Premium ($45+): Dr. Jart+ Cicapair ($48-52)
By Skin Tone Considerations:
- All Skin Tones: Mustela Cicastela, TOCOBO Cica Calming, Uriage Cica Daily
- May Leave White Cast: La Roche-Posay Cicaplast, Avène Cicalfate+, TOSOWOONG SOS Repair
- Single Shade Issues: Dr. Jart+ Cicapair (only suits fair-medium skin)
Frequently Asked Questions
What makes cica creams different from regular moisturizers?
Cica (centella asiatica) creams contain active compounds – madecassoside, asiaticoside, and madecassic acid – that specifically target skin barrier repair and inflammation. Unlike regular moisturizers that simply hydrate, cica creams actively heal compromised skin, reduce redness, and strengthen the skin barrier. They're designed for damaged, irritated, or reactive skin rather than everyday hydration.
Can I use cica cream every day?
Yes, most cica creams are gentle enough for daily use. However, some products like TOSOWOONG SOS Repair with 10% zinc oxide are better suited for nighttime or targeted treatment rather than daily all-over application. Lighter formulas like TOCOBO Cica Calming and Mustela Cicastela work beautifully as daily moisturizers.
Will cica creams cause breakouts?
It depends on the formula and your skin type. Products like La Roche-Posay Cicaplast and TOSOWOONG SOS Repair contain ingredients that can clog pores in acne-prone skin (shea butter, dimethicone, certain fatty acids). If you're acne-prone, choose non-comedogenic options like TOCOBO Cica Calming or Mustela Cicastela. All products with perfect 100/100 Yuka scores are generally safer, but individual reactions vary.
Are any of these safe for fungal acne?
Critical warning: TOSOWOONG SOS Repair and La Roche-Posay Cicaplast contain ingredients that feed Malassezia (the yeast causing fungal acne). These products will worsen fungal acne. TOCOBO Cica Calming is generally safer but check the full ingredient list against a fungal acne checker. When in doubt, consult a dermatologist.
How long until I see results from cica cream?
Results timeline varies by product and concern:
- Immediate soothing: Most products provide instant relief
- Redness reduction: 24-72 hours (La Roche-Posay, TOSOWOONG)
- Barrier repair: 1 hour to 7 days depending on product
- Texture improvement: 2-4 weeks with consistent use
- Eczema/rosacea management: 4-8 weeks for significant improvement
Can I use cica cream with retinol or vitamin C?
Absolutely – in fact, cica creams are ideal companions for actives. Apply vitamin C in the morning, then cica cream. Use retinol at night, followed by cica cream to minimize irritation. The soothing, barrier-repairing properties of cica counteract the drying and irritating effects of active ingredients. Many dermatologists specifically recommend cica creams for retinol users.
Why do some products have white cast?
Products containing zinc oxide or titanium dioxide (like La Roche-Posay, Avène, and TOSOWOONG) create a white cast that can be especially visible on darker skin tones. This typically fades as the product absorbs but may remain noticeable with thick application. If white cast is a concern, choose TOCOBO, Mustela, or Uriage instead.
Are these safe during pregnancy or breastfeeding?
Most cica creams are pregnancy-safe since centella asiatica is a botanical ingredient. However, always check with your healthcare provider. Products like Mustela Cicastela are specifically formulated for babies and nursing mothers. Avoid products with retinol, high-concentration vitamin C, or essential oils during pregnancy – Dr. Jart+ Cicapair contains essential oils, so consult your doctor.
Can I use these on my body, not just face?
Yes! All seven products work on face and body. They're particularly effective for:
- Diaper rash and baby skin issues (Mustela)
- Eczema patches anywhere (Avène)
- Post-waxing irritation (La Roche-Posay)
- Tattoo healing (La Roche-Posay, Avène)
- Sunburn (all products)
- Minor cuts and scrapes (all products)
Note that the 40-50ml sizes deplete quickly with body application – consider larger sizes where available.
What's the difference between French pharmacy and K-beauty cica creams?
French pharmacy brands (La Roche-Posay, Avène, Uriage) tend to be:
- Thicker, more occlusive textures
- Zinc/copper mineral complexes
- Clinical, pharmaceutical approach
- Often white cast
K-beauty brands (Dr. Jart+, TOSOWOONG, TOCOBO) tend to be:
- Lighter, more elegant textures
- Fermented or enhanced centella extracts
- Multi-step skincare integration
- Color-correcting or cosmetically elegant
Both are effective – choose based on your texture preference and skin type.
The Bottom Line
Choosing a clean cica cream doesn't mean settling for ineffective formulas or accepting heavy, pore-clogging textures. These seven Yuka-approved options prove you can have powerful barrier repair with safe, clean ingredients.
Our top pick for most people is La Roche-Posay Cicaplast Baume B5 – the cult-favorite delivers proven results for barrier repair, post-retinol recovery, and general irritation at an accessible price point. Its 90/100 Yuka score reflects excellent safety with minor deductions for certain ingredients.
However, if you have oily or acne-prone skin, choose TOCOBO Cica Calming Gel Cream – its lightweight texture and 98% satisfaction rate make it the rare cica cream that won't clog pores. For rosacea or eczema, Avène Cicalfate+ offers pharmaceutical-grade healing with National Eczema Association approval. And for families with babies, Mustela Cicastela provides the safest, most versatile option with a perfect 100/100 Yuka score.
Remember: the best cica cream is the one that matches your skin type and concerns. Pay attention to texture (rich vs. lightweight), comedogenic ingredients (especially if acne-prone), and white cast (especially if you have darker skin). Your compromised skin barrier will thank you for choosing wisely.
Yuka Approved
We're dedicated to finding and reviewing the cleanest, safest skincare using Yuka's scientific analysis. Follow us for weekly reviews of Yuka-approved products that actually work.